One Man's Fish Is Another Man's Poison
Final Fantasy XIV
Type Class
Reward 489,600 EXP 2,439 gil
Rewards Hallowed Chestnut Fishing Rod, 50 Fiend Worms, Aetherfishing
Reward Options Gatherer's Guerdon Materia IV or Gatherer's Guile Materia IV or Gatherer's Grasp Materia IV
Class Fisher
Level 58
Prerequisites FSH Lv.58, Invasion of the Supper Snatchers
Starting NPC Ansaulme
Area Foundation
Location The Forgotten Knight
Coordinates (X:13 Y:11)
Required Letter Puffer ∗
Compare One Man's Fish Is Another Man's Poison to other Quests
r M m R Items: Required to Complete One Man's Fish Is Another Man's Poison – 1 shown
c
Type:
Gray-named legacy items were available in 1.0 but can no longer be obtained
Name
The list of effects of consuming this item; most such effects are given as a percentage increase to a single attribute, though some items (not marked with a % sign) offer a flat bonus; the numbers in parenthesis denote the maximum bonus and the attribute total at which that bonus is reached; items will have their maximum effect on any attribute greater than or equal to this number
Attributes		 Recast Duration
A bonus to EXP earned while you are under the effects of this food
EXP		 Type Price Value
Gray-named legacy items were available in 1.0 but can no longer be obtained
Name
The list of effects of consuming this item; most such effects are given as a percentage increase to a single attribute, though some items (not marked with a % sign) offer a flat bonus; the numbers in parenthesis denote the maximum bonus and the attribute total at which that bonus is reached; items will have their maximum effect on any attribute greater than or equal to this number
Attributes		 Recast Duration
A bonus to EXP earned while you are under the effects of this food
EXP		 Type Price Value
Letter Puffer ∗ - - - - Seafood - 187 gil
r M m R Abilities: Earned in One Man's Fish Is Another Man's Poison – 1 shown
c
Shared abilities can be used by classes other than the one that learns them; quested abilities are not learned during the course of normal leveling, but rather are earned as quest rewards; main commands are available to all characters
Name
The class or job that learns this ability
Class
The level at which the listed class or job learns this ability; levels marked with a 'Q' indicate that a quest must be completed to earn the ability; other abilities are learned automatically at the indicated level
Level		 Type Range Radius
The casting time of this ability; if the value is a percentage, the ability takes that percentage of the global cooldown to cast
Cast
The recast time of the ability; abilities with a 'Global' recast share the same recast timer, which is determined by your character's attributes and gear
Recast
Some abilities require TP, MP, or HP to use; MP costs are multiplied by a value based on your current class and level; some abilities use a percentage of your maximum point total in place of a flat cost
Cost
The classes and job that can assign this ability
Affinity
Traits are automatically assigned based on your current class and level, while all other abilities must be assigned to the action bar
Category
Shared abilities can be used by classes other than the one that learns them; quested abilities are not learned during the course of normal leveling, but rather are earned as quest rewards; main commands are available to all characters
Name
The class or job that learns this ability
Class
The level at which the listed class or job learns this ability; levels marked with a 'Q' indicate that a quest must be completed to earn the ability; other abilities are learned automatically at the indicated level
Level		 Type Range Radius
The casting time of this ability; if the value is a percentage, the ability takes that percentage of the global cooldown to cast
Cast
The recast time of the ability; abilities with a 'Global' recast share the same recast timer, which is determined by your character's attributes and gear
Recast
Some abilities require TP, MP, or HP to use; MP costs are multiplied by a value based on your current class and level; some abilities use a percentage of your maximum point total in place of a flat cost
Cost
The classes and job that can assign this ability
Affinity
Traits are automatically assigned based on your current class and level, while all other abilities must be assigned to the action bar
Category
Aetherfishing Fisher Q58 - - - - - - FSH Trait
r M m R Quests: Prerequisite for One Man's Fish Is Another Man's Poison – 1 shown
c
Name Type Subype
These quests only appear during the main plot of one of the three cities or to members of a particular Grand Company; you will not see them if you are from another city or join anoher Grand Company
Plotline		 Level
The amount of experience awarded when completing this quest; some quests give varied amounts of experience based on your current level
EXP		 Gil
You earn all of these rewards when the quest is completed, independent of optional rewards
Rewards
You may choose one listed optional reward when the quest is completed
Reward Options		 Prerequisites Starting NPC
Name Type Subype
These quests only appear during the main plot of one of the three cities or to members of a particular Grand Company; you will not see them if you are from another city or join anoher Grand Company
Plotline		 Level
The amount of experience awarded when completing this quest; some quests give varied amounts of experience based on your current level
EXP		 Gil
You earn all of these rewards when the quest is completed, independent of optional rewards
Rewards
You may choose one listed optional reward when the quest is completed
Reward Options		 Prerequisites Starting NPC
Invasion of the Supper Snatchers Class Fisher - 55 322,560 1,811 gil Dark Chestnut Fishing Rod, 50 Magma Worms, Hellfishing Dhalmelskin Bush Hat or Dhalmelskin Vest or Wyvernskin Field Belt or Ramie Trousers of Gathering or 4 Allagan Silver Pieces FSH Lv.55, The Icepick Challenge Ansaulme
r M m R Quests: Follow-up to One Man's Fish Is Another Man's Poison – 1 shown
c
Name Type Subype
These quests only appear during the main plot of one of the three cities or to members of a particular Grand Company; you will not see them if you are from another city or join anoher Grand Company
Plotline		 Level
The amount of experience awarded when completing this quest; some quests give varied amounts of experience based on your current level
EXP		 Gil
You earn all of these rewards when the quest is completed, independent of optional rewards
Rewards
You may choose one listed optional reward when the quest is completed
Reward Options		 Prerequisites Starting NPC
Name Type Subype
These quests only appear during the main plot of one of the three cities or to members of a particular Grand Company; you will not see them if you are from another city or join anoher Grand Company
Plotline		 Level
The amount of experience awarded when completing this quest; some quests give varied amounts of experience based on your current level
EXP		 Gil
You earn all of these rewards when the quest is completed, independent of optional rewards
Rewards
You may choose one listed optional reward when the quest is completed
Reward Options		 Prerequisites Starting NPC
Carpe Diem Class Fisher - 60 - 2,388 gil 3 Hi-Cordials, Patience II 3 Gatherer's Guerdon Materia IV or 3 Gatherer's Guile Materia IV or 3 Gatherer's Grasp Materia IV FSH Lv.60, One Man's Fish Is Another Man's Poison Ansaulme
r M m R Arms & Tools: Earned in One Man's Fish Is Another Man's Poison – 2 shown
c
Name Dmg.
The DPS of auto attacks made with this weapon (calculated as auto attack damage divided by delay)
DPS
Aetherial arms have extra, randomly chosen bonuses in addition to those listed here
Bonuses
The item level of this arm or tool, which indicates its relative power
iLvl		 Level Class
 Dmg. Type Type
The number of materia slots this arm or tool has
Materia
The class required to repair this arm or tool; this is typically the same class as the one that can craft or attach materia to this arm or tool
Craft		 Price
Aetherial arms can be worth more than the listed amount, depending on the bonuses they have
Value
Name Dmg.
The DPS of auto attacks made with this weapon (calculated as auto attack damage divided by delay)
DPS
Aetherial arms have extra, randomly chosen bonuses in addition to those listed here
Bonuses
The item level of this arm or tool, which indicates its relative power
iLvl		 Level Class
 Dmg. Type Type
The number of materia slots this arm or tool has
Materia
The class required to repair this arm or tool; this is typically the same class as the one that can craft or attach materia to this arm or tool
Craft		 Price
Aetherial arms can be worth more than the listed amount, depending on the bonuses they have
Value
Fiend Worm - - - 145 58 FSH - Tackle - - 1 gil
Hallowed Chestnut Fishing Rod 27 9.00 Gathering +167, Perception +95 120 57 FSH Physical Primary Tool 1 CRP 18,627 gil 280 gil
r M m R Items: Earned in One Man's Fish Is Another Man's Poison – 3 shown
c
Type:
Gray-named legacy items were available in 1.0 but can no longer be obtained
Name
The list of effects of consuming this item; most such effects are given as a percentage increase to a single attribute, though some items (not marked with a % sign) offer a flat bonus; the numbers in parenthesis denote the maximum bonus and the attribute total at which that bonus is reached; items will have their maximum effect on any attribute greater than or equal to this number
Attributes		 Recast Duration
A bonus to EXP earned while you are under the effects of this food
EXP		 Type Price Value
Gray-named legacy items were available in 1.0 but can no longer be obtained
Name
The list of effects of consuming this item; most such effects are given as a percentage increase to a single attribute, though some items (not marked with a % sign) offer a flat bonus; the numbers in parenthesis denote the maximum bonus and the attribute total at which that bonus is reached; items will have their maximum effect on any attribute greater than or equal to this number
Attributes		 Recast Duration
A bonus to EXP earned while you are under the effects of this food
EXP		 Type Price Value
Gatherer's Grasp Materia IV GP +4 - - - Materia - 792 gil
Gatherer's Guerdon Materia IV Gathering +6 - - - Materia - 792 gil
Gatherer's Guile Materia IV Perception +6 - - - Materia - 792 gil
r M m R NPCs: Involved in One Man's Fish Is Another Man's Poison – 4 shown
c
Name Area Location Coordinates
Whether this NPC is the starting or ending NPC for this quest; some NPCs will both start and end the same quest
Role
Name Area Location Coordinates
Whether this NPC is the starting or ending NPC for this quest; some NPCs will both start and end the same quest
Role
Ansaulme Foundation The Forgotten Knight (X:13 Y:11) Start/End
Sisipu Limsa Lominsa Lower Decks Fisherman's Bottom (X:7 Y:14) -
Mogukk The Churning Mists Landlord Colony (X:31 Y:26) -
Mogtoe The Churning Mists Moghome (X:30 Y:36) -